Les Miserablés: Comparing Three Marius Pontmercys

Many people have mixed feelings about Les Misérables’ Marius: he is a fickle character whose love-at-first-sight experience with Cosette, which is ridiculous in itself, allows him to endanger the lives of his friends on the barricades, and he undoubtedly contributes to the demise and weariness of Jean Valjean by getting in between him and Cosette. However, he is the romantic hero and does at least try to help his friends, even if it is somewhat misplaced, so he is still at least partially sympathetic.

With such a complicated “Marmite” character, it is essential for the musical that the singer portraying Marius is able to display this conflicting range of emotion with the flawless voice of a young, handsome lead. It is therefore interesting to compare the three most famous portrayals of the character – Michael Ball, the original, Nick Jonas in the 25th anniversary concert and Eddie Redmayne in the global smash-hit film – to see how much difference a voice makes.

nick-jonas-les-mis
Nick Jonas.

Let’s start with the worst. Nick Jonas was clearly the mass appeal choice for the O2 concerts, designed to draw in normal punters as well as musical aficionados, a role he arguably shared with Matt Lucas since every other lead role was filled with a West End regular. He doesn’t have a bad pop voice, but it came across as too weak to carry many of Marius’ powerful lines, especially during One Day More, and he clearly found it harder to fill the vast space of the O2 than he would have done in his role as a Jonas Brother.

During One Day More, Nick stands quite rigidly whilst singing towards Cosette (an aspect which does recur throughout the show) and it largely feels like he’s just slightly on top of the note instead of comfortably singing through it; the nasally tone to his voice doesn’t help that either.

The unfortunate thing is that he could actually get away with this singing style for the indecisive, lovesick Marius (it certainly works in A Heart Full Of Love), but Ramin Karimloo’s Enjolras’ entry in this song for their alternating verse totally overpowers and overshadows him. His other biggest failing is on the “my place is here, I fight with you” line: it is supposed to be one of the most dramatic in this massive song, but he makes each line too clipped and abrupt, making it lose its weight.

The most annoying thing Nick does is use his pop inflections in Empty Chairs At Empty Tables; from the very first verse, he uses little slides and vowel emphases that make the song devoid of any emotion and make it purely a vocal performance.

Luckily, if you want to hear emotion in Empty Chairs, you need look no further than Eddie Redmayne’s embodiment of Marius in the 2012 movie. His version of the song, in which we vividly see him in the room in which he used to meet his friends and in which some of them died, concentrates much more on its grief-stricken nature; Eddie didn’t have to sacrifice his vocals, but instead could make them more quiet and intimate, a bonus of singing close up to movie cameras instead of having to project to a whole audience. He also replicates this devastating emotion during A Little Fall Of Rain, the duet with Eponine (Samantha Barks).

Eddie Redmayne sobs through Empty Chairs At Empty Tables.
Eddie Redmayne sobs through Empty Chairs At Empty Tables.

Equally, in One Day More, Eddie manages to perfectly contrast his two duet sections with Cosette and Enjolras, as in the former he floats effectively on the high notes, matching Amanda Seyfried’s thin soprano, and then he immediately sounds more resolute and full-voiced as he questions his purpose at the barricades alongside Enjolras. This isn’t easy to make sound so effortless, but he portrays both sides of Marius empathetically and admirably.

As accomplished as Eddie Redmayne was in the movie – especially considering his singing ability was previously largely unheard of, and despite the fact he didn’t receive the award recognition he deserved – there are few who can rival the original Marius, Michael Ball. It was unfortunate for Nick Jonas that the encore at the 25th anniversary concert featured some of the original cast singing One Day More, with Michael showing him how it’s done!

One of the best examples of Michael’s Marius is at the beginning of A Heart Full Of Love, in the way his vibrato-filled voice is able to start extremely tentatively but become more confident; this is notable throughout in the difference between lyrics like ‘for shame, I do not even know your name’ and ‘never go away’. Although his Empty Chairs is less devastating than Eddie’s version, that’s largely due to the difference between the stage and theatre mediums; Michael had to project more out of necessity, but he does use this to his advantage, creating a more powerful and tumultuous feeling, especially at ‘oh my friends, my friends, don’t ask me’.

Michael Ball.
Michael Ball.

Despite Michael’s all-round vocal prowess, there is one moment in the musical that he is still remembered for: on the line ‘my place is here, I fight with you’ in One Day More, he does a little slide down from ‘here’ which links the two halves of the line quite well and has become his trademark style. The difference between this and Nick Jonas’ slides is that Michael’s are more carefully crafted, whereas Nick’s just seem to come from his pop tendencies. Michael even joked about this trademark of his to Eddie at the movie premiere, where the latter insisted he hadn’t copied it for fear of being lambasted!

Overall, the singers’ results are quite clear. Nick Jonas seemed to succeed in his job of encouraging younger fans to see the Les Mis experience, and he wasn’t awful in the process; he just couldn’t match up to the more emotive singers/actors singing some difficult music. Eddie Redmayne and Michael Ball should both be congratulated in different ways; Michael will always be the definitive Marius, after many years of singing the music and debuting it in the first place, but it would be hard to find someone better than Eddie to adapt the character and his music to the film medium.

A special mention must also go to Craig Mather, who was Marius in the West End when I saw the show in 2012 and who very successfully brought across Marius’ cluelessness and innocence. Let’s hope his name is soon as famous as those of the other three.

Les-Miserables-Poster-68168_650x400-e13601196065991

Advertisements

9 thoughts on “Les Miserablés: Comparing Three Marius Pontmercys

  1. Em Scotcher August 30, 2013 / 11:43 AM

    Eddie Redmayne redefined Marius for me – Michael Ball’s vocals are outstanding, but Eddie is definitely the first Marius I’ve actually come away liking as much as some of the other, stronger characters! Again, the medium of film has helped hugely, since they could close in on his face and give the audience an intimate look at his emotions.

    Love this post!

    • charlottetobitt August 30, 2013 / 11:53 AM

      So glad you agree- I was seriously worried that some hardcore musical fans would tell me off for praising Eddie so highly compared to Michael, but he absolutely blew me away!

  2. French Fancy March 8, 2014 / 6:17 AM

    I only saw the 25th anniversary concert last night. One of the highlights of the 10th anniversary for me was Michael Ball, my favourite west end tenor. I had no idea who Jonas was but, from the moment he opened his mouth, I was struck with horror at his weedy voice and lack of stage presence, also his accent (I didn’t know he was American at that point) – he could not hold a note in a normal west end accent (well, unless you’re talking about a cowhand in Oklahoma perhaps). He ruined the show for me. He really was the weakest link.
    And as for Eddie Redmayne being better than Michael Ball – don’t be daft!

  3. jbo February 5, 2015 / 1:54 AM

    I literally just got the 25 anniversary DVD in the mail today. Michael ball made Marius my favorite character and I like his songs. I saw a brief clip of Nick Jonas as Marius on YouTube so I knew it was gonna be bad. But it was worse than I thought it would be. His whole performance I mean. Choices for Valjean, Enjolras, and Javert made up for it a bit.

  4. Chloe McCluskey April 29, 2015 / 9:59 PM

    I can honestly say I’ve never liked Michael Ball. I find him to be what my performer friends and I can a ‘note hogger’. He likes to make sure his voice is the last voice you hear on a note. But Eddie Redmayne’s Empty Chairs has to be the most beautiful thing I’ve ever heard.

    • charlottetobitt May 21, 2015 / 1:58 PM

      Fair enough re Michael Ball! I totally get that he isn’t for everyone. I’m so glad you agree about Eddie though, very few songs make me cry but that rendition has done

  5. Kelly w September 12, 2015 / 6:52 PM

    I feel one major factor to remember on the subject of nick jonas as Marius is that he had only just turned 17 a mere couple weeks before the anniversary concert and this may also have something to do with the power behind his voice I don’t feel he was mature enough to completely fill the brief but nor do I feel he did a terrible job at it. I can’t say that Jonas did any worse than the girl playing Fantine who was rather flat at times during her performance!

    • charlottetobitt September 12, 2015 / 10:37 PM

      Good point! It’s a shame he couldn’t try it a few years later maybe. I don’t remember having a problem with Fantine though!

  6. Joel December 10, 2015 / 4:00 PM

    The way I came across this article was Google Searching: “Marius in the 25th Anniversary Les Mis is a Bitch.” That nasaly voice made me stop watching before I got to Empty Chairs & Empty Tables. I just couldn’t imagine the butchering. Thanks for affirming my fears but with reason why he was casted. Still, he makes the character seem like such a bitch. That Michael Ball guy gave it balls.

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s